Victoria Needs a Fast-Track List for Building Claims

Yesterday I wrote about the cost of litigation in Australia and how a $250,000 claim can become economically unfeasible to pursue.

But there is another part of the problem.

Why are building disputes under $500,000 being run through processes designed for much larger litigation?

Our VCAT Act and rules and in County Court of Victoria apply the same rules equally to small, medium and large claims.

We have to accept small claims just can’t be economically run at all, but we are basically brandishing mid level claims to let the loss lie where it falls…especially in building cases with the cost of expert evidence, proportionate liability and multi party respondent/defendants being the norm makes costs as prohibitive as the damages being pursued.

Why should a $100k dispute be forced through the same process as a $10million dispute?

It just denies access to justice due to cost.

In Victoria, to build confidence for owners we need a fast-track building list for claims under $500,000:

  • Standard procedural orders issued immediately.
  • Strict, short timetables for pleadings and evidence.
  • Default judgment at VCAT where a party repeatedly fails to comply with orders.
  • One strike for expert evidence that is unnecessarily late particularly where there is a pattern of using experts to delay proceedings.
  • No new expert conclaves simply because the timetable has become inconvenient.
  • An early two-hour mediation within 3 months of all expert reports filed.
  • A final hearing within a defined period not years later and set at the start of the process.

The objective isn’t to give homeowners an advantage. It is to make the process proportionate to the dispute.

Plus Joinder has become a back door way for defendant delay. If pleadings and expert evidence are required efficiently and without delay Joinder should also be closed after pleadings.

Here’s the point If someone has a $200,000 building defect claim, spending another $200,000 getting to a hearing isn’t access to justice.

We need a system that works:

  • Because at the moment we are punishing good builders to compete with crooks who game the system and leave losses with owners;

  • Why? We need homes built and confidence is lost in a system that supports bad builders and plumbers, insurers, defendants, respondents and insurance defence lawyers.

If I was an arbitrator in a fast track list, I wouldn’t put up with any nonsense. Evidence in on time or miss out. Let me tell you, we would start seeing better building fast as the shonky operators saw there was no where to hide but do it right the first time.

That is the reform we need to be talking about because bad builders who game the system are rewarded by cost and delay and a housing mess unfolds at this coal face where confidence rests.

This article is a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Recent articles

Book an online appointment with our Principal Lawyer today

Book an appointment