What If the Problem With Litigation Is How We Fund It?
What if the problem with litigation is how we fund it?
I want to start a conversation about changing the way mid scale litigation is funded in Australia.
I regularly see building and property disputes where the claim is worth hundreds of thousands of dollars but proving the claim costs so much that the claimant struggles to justify pursuing it.
Take a $100,000 - 250,000 building defect claim.
The homeowner may need a building expert, structural engineer, quantity surveyor, hydraulic expert and lawyers.
Before the court can even determine who is right, usually the same amount of $100,000 - $250,000 will need to be spent.
Hundreds of thousands of dollars to establish the case. Plus the mediation process and expert conclave (which are useful in larger cases) just drive up more costs and delay and pressure plaintiffs to settle low and recover sunk costs.
So what happens?
The homeowner may have a valid $250,000 claim but they have to put up $250,000 to recover it.
That is an access-to-justice problem. Spending a dollar to chase a dollar doesn’t make sense.
The system is broken. It takes years to progress at VCAT and up to 7 years in many cases which is outrageous.
That just gives defendants the motivation to drive costs to a breaking point and a claimant to settle low.
However there is another way…
And I think we need to have this more fundamental conversation:
Why aren’t there (1) fast track processes for under $500,000 claims; and (2) all the reasonable costs of recovering a loss potentially part of the loss itself?
I’m not suggesting that every legal bill should automatically be recoverable. There are safeguards around reasonableness, proportionality and conduct.
But if a defendant has caused $250,000 of damage and the claimant has had to spend $250,000 reasonably proving and recovering that loss, shouldn’t the claimant be not only refunded but rewarded? Their costs recovered and:
say punitive damages;
costs of funding litigation such as interest and fees recoverable too.
The current system can produce an extraordinary result:
You can win your case and still lose financially.
I think Australia needs to seriously examine supporting litigation funding costs to even the scales with the unfair advantage that insured parties have.
Building disputes are an obvious place to start because expert evidence can be extraordinarily expensive.
But the issue is much bigger than construction law.
It goes to the basic question of whether having a legal right means very much if you cannot afford to enforce it. We need fast track legal processes for smaller claims.
I’m interested in starting a serious conversation about changing this.
This article is a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.
Building cases at VCAT can take seven years. The answer is not another layer of bureaucracy. It is a properly funded tribunal that works.
Why professionals and brokers cannot rely on s 54 of the Insurance Contracts Act to rescue a failure to notify circumstances that might give rise to a claim.
Recent decisions show why you should notify your PI insurer of circumstances early, in writing and in enough detail, even if you believe you did nothing wrong.
The right question is not whether you have a claim. It is what facts exist that may give rise to one, and whether you have notified them under s 40(3).