Section 54 Won't Save a Late PI Notification
Section 54 won’t save you if you fail to notify circumstances that might give rise to a claim.
There is an important distinction in Australian insurance law that every professional with PI insurance and brokers placing PI should understand.
In FAI Insurance Ltd v Australian Hospital Care Pty Ltd (2001) 204 CLR 641 (“AHC”) the High Court confirmed that s 54 of the Insurance Contracts Act can, in the right circumstances, protect an insured who fails to notify an insurer in accordance with a policy’s notification requirements.
But you would be wrong to assume that means you can rely on s 54 to notify a late claim.
The policy in AHC contained a deeming clause. That matters because the clause allowed circumstances notified during the policy period to be treated as a claim made during that period.
Section 54 could therefore operate on the contractual notification requirement.
Section 54 won’t operate on the statutory right under section 40 (3)
Therefore the position is different where the insured is relying on s 40(3) of the Act to obtain an extension of cover for a claim made after the policy period.
In the recent case of Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v Uniting Church in Australia Property Trust (NSW) [2025] FCAFC 8, the Full Federal Court held that s 54 could not rescue a failure to notify circumstances as soon as reasonably practicable under s 40(3). The High Court subsequently refused special leave to appeal.
The practical lesson? Don’t assume s 54 will rescue you.
Modern PI and other claims made policies will almost categorically not include a deeming clause. Albeit, I occasionally see one, usually a Lloyds of London issued where international underwriters don’t understand the unique statutory provisions in Australia.
But here is the point:
Trust me, defending a claim whilst also debating a claim with your insurer are two fronts of litigation you don’t want.
Don’t wait until a formal demand arrives. Don’t assume that because you believe someone else was at fault you have nothing to worry about. And don’t assume that your insurer will be obliged to cover you years later.
I see too many professionals who either misunderstand claims versus notifications or retain brokers who aren’t specialised enough to properly advise.
That distinction can determine whether you have insurance when you need it most.
Your PI insurance is supposed to protect you. But you need to preserve your entitlement to that protection.
This article is a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.
Building cases at VCAT can take seven years. The answer is not another layer of bureaucracy. It is a properly funded tribunal that works.
Why professionals and brokers cannot rely on s 54 of the Insurance Contracts Act to rescue a failure to notify circumstances that might give rise to a claim.
Recent decisions show why you should notify your PI insurer of circumstances early, in writing and in enough detail, even if you believe you did nothing wrong.
The right question is not whether you have a claim. It is what facts exist that may give rise to one, and whether you have notified them under s 40(3).