What Facts Must You Notify to Your PI Insurer?

IF YOU BUY PROFESSIONAL INDEMNITY

AND EVER WANT TO CLAIM…

YOU NEED TO HEAR THIS!

Most professionals ask:

“Do I have a claim?”

Wrong question!

The right question is:

“What facts exist that may give rise to a claim?”

You DON’T need to know:

  • who the claimant is;
  • what the loss is;
  • or it’s certain to be a claim!

You just NEED to know that there are 2 types of notifications

  1. A CLAIM

    • Proceedings or a letter of demand. EASY.
  2. Section 40 (3) notification

    • Circumstances that may give rise to claim later.

And if you’re broker doesn’t get it reach out to me. I recommend great PI brokers all the time.

AND STOP SAYING:

“But I don’t think the client has a claim.”

Or:

“I don’t want my premium to go up.”

The egg on your face anology is YOU after failing to notify circumstances that NEEDED to be notified.

OR

Dealing with a broker who doesn’t get it!

Remember:

  • PI claims are the type of claims that save your career, business and reputation.

  • PI denials are what really test you. I deal with them daily and trust me you don’t want to engage me if you can help it!

PLUS:

  • If you are changing insurers each year you are facing heightened risk.

  • If you don’t change often you still face risk, you should get your broker to insert a continuous cover clause that provides protection.

The simple point is this:

If you get sued in 2027;

BUT in 2026:

You stuffed up some calculations, design, certification or advice you should probably be notifying your insurer now but definitely getting advice on what to do.

Because the 2026 insurer will ask:

“When did you first become aware of the circumstances giving rise to this claim?”

Section 40(3) is your friend if you use it properly.

It effectively says that if during the policy period, you become aware of facts that might give rise to a claim, and you notify your insurer in writing as soon as reasonably practicable, the insurer cannot refuse the later claim merely because the actual claim was made after the policy expired!

If something has gone wrong:

  • an error,
  • omission,
  • missed deadline,
  • professional mistake,

Whatever!

Get advice. TELL YOUR EXPERT PI BROKER (who acts for you). Or call me. But don’t:

‘Sit on your hands’

Or

‘Put your head in the sand’

These are sure ways to get

‘Egg on your face’

The High Court in CGU Insurance Ltd v Porthouse illustrates why putting to much weight on what you think might become a claim is danger.

The objective standard being found to be what a reasonable professional in the insured’s position would have thought might result in an allegation.

So it doesn’t really matter what you subjectively think.

A PI policy will contain a prior known circumstances exclusion. Don’t test it out!

I regularly deal with denied professional indemnity claims and I know that YOU don’t want to be the one with egg on your face!

This article is a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Recent articles

Book an online appointment with our Principal Lawyer today

Book an appointment