PI Insurance: A Warning to Every Professional
PI INSURANCE: A WARNING TO EVERY PROFESSIONAL
Yesterday, I wrote about the importance of notifying your PI insurer of circumstances that may give rise to a claim.
Two recent decisions reinforce why getting this right matters.
Section 40(3) of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 can protect you when you notify your insurer in writing of facts that might give rise to a claim, as soon as reasonably practicable after becoming aware of them and before your policy expires.
The subsequent claim can then be made after the policy expires and connect back to that original notification.
However, too many insureds look at this as an option to protect them only. They fail to appreciate that a prior know claims exclusion on a future policy may later exclude the claim if they held sufficient details in an earlier year policy and failed to notify.
The recent Allianz decision demonstrates the danger of knowing about circumstances that might lead to claims but failing to notify them in time.
You don’t necessarily need a demand, complaint or proceedings before you notify.
If you know facts that might give rise to a claim, the time to think about notification is then.
In P & S Kauter Investments Pty Ltd v Arch Underwriting at Lloyds Ltd [2021] NSWCA 136, the notification was insufficient because it did not provide enough factual substance to establish a realistic possibility of a claim.
Simply telling your insurer that something has gone wrong may not be enough.
You need to identify the relevant circumstances, to the extent they are known.
You don’t need to prove negligence or establish liability first.
You may genuinely believe someone else caused the problem or that your work was correct.
But the question is whether the facts you know might give rise to a claim not simply whether you believe you are liable.
If something goes wrong, ask yourself:
Most importantly, get legal advice. Get legal advice from a specialist professional indemnity lawyer who knows the caselaw and knows the risks and benefits.
I see too many brokers getting this wrong and not understanding the caselaw.
I’ve worked in insurance and law for over 2 years as both a broker and lawyer. I still see professionals underestimate the importance of notifying circumstances.
Don’t wait for a claim to discover you should have notified the circumstances years earlier.
This article is a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.
Building cases at VCAT can take seven years. The answer is not another layer of bureaucracy. It is a properly funded tribunal that works.
Why professionals and brokers cannot rely on s 54 of the Insurance Contracts Act to rescue a failure to notify circumstances that might give rise to a claim.
Recent decisions show why you should notify your PI insurer of circumstances early, in writing and in enough detail, even if you believe you did nothing wrong.
The right question is not whether you have a claim. It is what facts exist that may give rise to one, and whether you have notified them under s 40(3).