Fix VCAT: Justice Delayed Is Justice Denied in Victoria

Fix our tribunal system in Victoria.

Justice delayed is justice denied.

We all know that quote…it is tiring BUT it is true. And a person on average lives to just over 70 in Australia and yet it is not uncommon to see a building case at VCAT go for 7 years.

Justice that takes a tenth of a lifetime. Come on, that is not justice.

We have become a joke of the Western world when it comes to the timely administration of justice.

AND I don’t criticise VCAT members. They are doing an admirable job under extreme pressure.

My criticism is levelled at the Victorian government that has allowed the system to reach this point.

Our courts are not perfect, but they are working on improving practice notes, procedures and case management. They are more efficient. Have processes for default judgement and court rule timeframes for filing defences immediately upon service of statement of claim.

However, filing at VCAT means you might need to wait 3 to 6 months to just get orders. Maybe you’ll wait for a year or more for a mediation date but then it’ll be cancelled because the Respondent will delay and the Tribunal doesn’t have the sufficient tools or resources to stop this type of delay.

Meanwhile, people with building defects, water ingress and other property disputes can wait years for justice.

And I am REALLY sick of hearing uninformed people suggest another layer of regulation, another ombudsman or another commissioner to address problems caused by delays in the justice system.

Stop creating more bureaucracy. Fix the tribunal and fund it properly.

Adding another institution does not solve a backlog. It risks adding more cost, complexity and delay. We need government to face facts, provide adequate resources and make the system work.

Delay always benefits Respondents, particularly insurers, who retain money while claimants wait. And now our government/regulators have a conflict of interest where the VMIA and now BPC (statutory body as insurer for DBI) benefits from that delay. Think about that!

Meanwhile, ordinary property owners carry the financial burden and live with unresolved problems.

I call on the Victorian Government to acknowledge this failure and fix it. Government will only address this if the noise grows louder.

And if the states cannot run their tribunal systems consistently and properly, perhaps the Australian Government should lead the way towards a national tribunal system.

Access to justice should mean more than the right to join a queue that lasts for years.

Enough talk. Fund the system. Fix the tribunal. Deliver justice.

This article is a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Recent articles

Book an online appointment with our Principal Lawyer today

Book an appointment