Why a Strata Commissioner Won't Fix Leaking Apartments

I saw this post proposing a Strata Commissioner for Victoria to address, amongst other things, leaking apartments!

To help apartment owners:

  • What we really need is VCAT to lift its game!

After all, what is a strata commissioner going to do about resolving:

  • Water Act claims; and
  • Builder Warranty claims.

These two key problems where VCAT has jurisdiction.

A Strata Commissioner is a new layer of bureaucracy and can’t order:

  1. Building defects to be fixed;
  2. Water ingress to be addressed.

As the Lord Mayor points out leaking roofs take too long to fix. That is true!

Water coming through ceilings, balconies, common property and other lots is a health hazard.

Mould developing inside apartments is something I hear about every day!

And the frustrating thing is that water ingress claims under section 16 of the Water Act are an effective solution but for the delays at VCAT.

Delays mean responsible parties simply don’t fix the problem until they have to!

People are living in unacceptable conditions while the dispute resolution system moves at snails pace.

VCAT is where the problem begins. Not a new solution like a strata commissioner.

So if I were running VCAT, I would introduce a Water Ingress Fast Track mechanism.

The moment an application is filed and supported by an expert report and points of claim identifying the cause of the ingress and the required rectification:

  1. Standard orders issued with technology support would be served on the parties.

  2. The respondent would have to file points of defence and expert evidence (say 30 - 60 days maximum).

Expert evidence should be exchanged quickly. After all we are dealing with a serious health hazard mould.

  1. The matter should be listed for directions promptly if the points of defence and expert evidence aren’t filed in time. And section 78 applications and cost orders for non compliant partes immediately considered.

I know this is a serious change but we have a problem with non-compliance in apartment rectification and water ingress because VCAT is too slow and lacks the tools to reach a result.

This is about recognising that water ingress and mould is different from an ordinary strata dispute.

Mould is the new asbestos and we can’t leave people living in unsafe conditions or homeless.

Plus things have got so slow at the VCAT it literally takes years….

I’m serious - Everyone waits for the Tribunal! FOREVER!

Many don’t even bother and then we get suggestions like a Strata Commissioner will fix water ingress in apartments.

Sorry, it isn’t that simple. You need to assess the POS for ownership of the cause, get expert evidence and prove your claim. That is Tribunal jurisdiction.

We don’t need another layer of administration. We need leaks fixed fast.

Strata is unique in lot owner and common property ownership and assuming a cause is simply determined - won’t solve the problem.

This article is a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Recent articles

Book an online appointment with our Principal Lawyer today

Book an appointment