The $250k Freerider: Why Mid-Value Claims Go Unpursued

A $250,000 legal right is not worth $250,000 if it costs $200,000 to enforce it.

This is the problem I keep seeing in homeowner litigation.

It is insurance is as important to me as building and property litigation.

Many of the claims I deal with involve recovery under various insurance policies like building, public liability, strata, plumber insurance, DBI and professional indemnity behind a builder, engineer, surveyor, architect or other professional.

Knowing where to look, what policy may respond, who can claim and exclusions has become my superpower!

But here is the bigger problem:

  • Homeowner insurance claims are hit and miss because of insurance terms AND it is often an alternative to a straight builder or developer claim being too costly!

  • Plus why should a wrongdoer builder or developer get away with causing a $100,000, $200,000 or $250,000 loss simply because the victim cannot afford to recover it?

Our system effectively says:

You may have a legal right

You can prove it

But if it costs too much to pursue - the loss lies where it falls

That creates a ‘Wrongdoer Benefit Principle’ which we should all want gone…

Think about it:

  • The person who benefits because the claim is too costly to pursue gets away with it;

  • Their insurance premiums stay lower than they should;

  • Our regulators have to work harder at more cost to keep them honest;

  • The real issue is we have a productivity problem:

the $250k Freerider is alive in Australia

Good builders, insurers and professionals should want this as much as my clients because they all compete in the same market but on unfair terms.

So let’s fix the economics.

For claims up to, say, $500,000 we need:

→ Fast-tracked proceedings. Trial on in 12 months not 5 years!

→ Standard technology enabled orders immediately issued upon filing at VCAT or County Court for approved <$500k claims.

→ Strict limits on timing and amount of expert evidence. Too late and miss out! Real consequences for delay.

→ Short, focused mediations.

→ And a defined, regulated component of reasonable litigation funding costs to be recoverable where the claim succeeds.

This doesn’t require any government spending.

It requires changing the rules so that smaller and mid-value claims are economical.

Why should building and buying the family home or the castle if you like - be so risky in Australia?

It shouldn’t!

And if you think this is theoretical it isn’t!

Just think of Darryl Kerrigan for a moment…

The reality is I meet a Darryl every day!

They join me my Teams Meeting and each for the first time says:

“how can the system be like this?”

Victoria can lead change and remove the shield for the $250k Freeriders that game the system. Bring back buyer confidence. Support good builders who do the right thing.

Plus we have the technology to make litigation efficient and low cost - let’s do it!

Let’s make the system work for the $100,000–$500,000 claim!

This article is a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Recent articles

Book an online appointment with our Principal Lawyer today

Book an appointment