How I Would Run the Big Build Royal Commission

The Royal Commission:

Someone said in my last post “Blair should be Counsel Assisting.”

I had to laugh. I am just a building solicitor with a concern for the state of this state - if you get what I mean!

But, if I was Counsel Assisting the Victorian Big Build Royal Commission there is something I wouldn’t do:

I wouldn’t start with the big wigs, yes I know it is what everyone wants the politicians, ex premiers or the big government bosses. BUT the big wigs can wait until all the evidence comes out.

Yes, every nepotistic alliance, every benefit, every overpriced job and benefit and follow the money from there…once every inch of detail and allowance, approval and payment is considered and who knew what would I make my way up.

Only then would I begin to “do the big wigs slowly”. Why? It sounds boring but we need the grease before we get the ‘I don’t recall’.

I’d start with the contractors.

Who was engaged? What did they contract for? What variations? Who did they know? Who did they meet? What did they tender? How didn’t that compare to comparable jobs outside the big build? Get the phone records get every interaction pre-engagement.

Then - Who engaged the subcontractors? Analyse them from every angle.

Who approved the variations?

Who was actually doing the work?

Who was being paid? What amount for what materials, what labour, what consultants? Stud the invoices, purchase orders, payments and receipts. Compare those to other disclosures for insurance, funding etc.

Who was talking to whom?

And most importantly:

What did you know, when did you know it, and who did you tell?

Only then I’d work my way up.

  • Subcontractors.
  • Labour hire.
  • Project managers.
  • Procurement officers.
  • Consultants.
  • Senior executives.

And once the evidence was assembled, then I’d call the big wigs. Not too soon. Becuase the devil is in the details. First start by finding out what happened at the coal face and follow the money.

Because the questions would be very different by then:

  • You were responsible for this project.
  • You say you didn’t know what was happening.
  • Why not?
  • Who was supposed to tell you?
  • What oversight took place?
  • How didn’t you know…

BUT moreover in my experience as a lawyer when you put together facts (and you know they’re facts) the lies just don’t fit anymore.

Even the ‘I don’t recall’ won’t stack up.

And finally:

How much did it cost Victorian taxpayers and how do we now recover it?

That’s how I’d run it.

Start at the bottom. Follow the evidence. Then work upwards. My end goal would not be finding out. It would be RECOVERY! Just like my day-to-day nothing is more important than getting the money back for the claimant. And in this case the claimant is ‘us’ taxpayers.

This article is a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Recent articles

Book an online appointment with our Principal Lawyer today

Book an appointment