Big Build Fraud and Commercial Crime Insurance Recovery

Show me the money! All $15billion!

We all know that great line, and that amount, but what does it have to do with building law?

The Royal Commission into Victoria’s major public and civil infrastructure projects has started with allegations of corruption, criminal conduct and serious misconduct across the construction sector which is now being examined.

It has already held closed hearings and has powers to compel documents and witnesses.

So what?

Well, as a building and insurance lawyer my specific expertise is RECOVERY.

You know! Investigating with a real purpose - to find the funds and getting it back for my client.

So for me, through this lense, I can’t help but look at the RC in this way.

The interesting question about this RC for me is what happens after the headlines.

I know that if wrongdoing is established, the real public interest will be:

Who got grilled? What titillating information came out…and it seems there is a general apathy from the public that anything positive will come of it.

But I am not interested in that, I want to know:

  1. Who actually suffered the loss?

  2. What money can be recovered?

  3. What insurance responds?

I am talking about RECOVERY. Proof. Action. Recovery.

I live and breathe recovery. So where there is fraud and intentional misconduct my mind immediately goes to classes of insurance and clauses.

First, the plethora of exclusions in professional indemnity insurance and directors and officers liability cover BUT these policies only cover defence costs and damages so they aren’t my present interest. I am sure they are of great interest to those witnesses looking for legal protection and they are probably closely studying insurer rights of recovery if such fraud is proven!

BUT I am thinking about fraud and crime insruance too.

Think about it, the modus operandi of how fraud for the big build was executed was through contractors and subbies AND those building businesses would typically hold an array of fraud policies, crime extensions under management liability insurance and commercial crime insurance.

Many business hold these policies and could cover losses. Maybe even statutory authorities if they have been involved would hold VMIA policies issues…

Contractors who have been misled, duped, de-frauded should be having a closer look at commercial crime insurance and thinking notification now not later.

Commercial crime insurance can cover both internal and external fraud including direct financial loss as a result of employees fraud or collusion with third parties.

Hello! That is exactly what seems to be about to come out.

If you are subcontractor or contractor you should be urgently looking to your broker and insurance program and making notification or discovery.

These are not Royal Commission questions. They are the questions that ultimately determine whether someone can actually recover money.

This article is a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Recent articles

Book an online appointment with our Principal Lawyer today

Book an appointment