A BPC Rectification Order Is Not the End of the Dispute

Victoria’s building law has just entered a very different era.

The BPC now has new powers to require defective, incomplete or non-compliant building work to be rectified and we are now starting to see orders issued.

So, proceedings at Court or VCAT to get a fix may not necessarily be required.

However, bear in mind proceedings for review may still be required if a rectification order is not satisfactory.

OR

Court or VCAT proceedings may still be required because orders are not simply a mechanism for ordering every defect identified by a homeowner to be fixed.

Whilst the BPC is developing policy parameters and practices governing when a Rectification Order may be issued, in short, it requires a pretty high bar. See my previous posts which comment on this.

The same issue arises in plumbing, where the BPC has different remedial tools including Requests to Rectify, Rectification Notices and Plumbing Orders.

But there is an important point that I think homeowners need to understand.

A BPC issued rectification order (even if one can be obtained) is not necessarily the same thing as a complete solution to the building problem.

There is a practical issue. Even when an order is made, the scope of the order may not necessarily capture everything that is required to properly investigate and rectify the underlying problem.

The order will be only as good as the detail in it. For example, what if additional damage is discovered when the works are being undertaken? What if the fix itself is non-compliant? What if some additional defect was not included in your complaint?

These distinctions are critical.

A crack may be the symptom. The movement underneath it may be the problem.

And fixing what is identified in an order is not necessarily the same as establishing the full cause of the loss and recovering the full cost of getting it right.

You need to still proactively seek expert opinion to ensure your BPC complaint is properly framed and supported by evidence. This includes:

  • What is actually wrong?
  • Is it non - compliance or something else?
  • What evidence proves this?
  • What and who caused it?
  • What work and method is required to rectify it?
  • How is the proposed method a reasonable and necessary way to address the rectification?

The new BPC powers are significant.

But I would caution against assuming that because the BPC has made an order, the problem is solved.

And that is precisely why independent technical and legal analysis remains important. If necessary, there are also rights of review (appeal) that can be made to VCAT that apply strict time limits too.

Remember - An order can be a very important step that avoids a more onerous legal process. But it is not necessarily the end of the building dispute.

This article is a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Recent articles

Book an online appointment with our Principal Lawyer today

Book an appointment