Maidstone Apartments: Are the Owners Out of Time?

Maidstone Apartment Structural Disaster: What if the owners are already out of time?

You can’t read the stories about the Maidstone apartment owners without feeling enormous sympathy for them.

Imagine buying a home for your family and then discovering the building is sinking.

Imagine being told the solution could cost $17–20 million.

And yet there is another problem that may be even more frustrating.

What if there is no viable legal claim left to pursue?

The buildings were constructed in about 2011.

Under s 134 of Victoria’s Building Act, a building action generally cannot be brought more than 10 years after the relevant occupancy permit.

That is a significant problem for owners discovering serious structural defects after that period.

The law does now allow a Tribunal or court in certain circumstances to extend the 10-year period. But that is not the same thing as having an unrestricted right to sue.

So the owners can quite properly investigate:

  • Who designed it?
  • Who built it?
  • Who certified it?
  • What went wrong?
  • What insurance existed?

But they may discover that the biggest obstacle isn’t proving that something went wrong.

It is getting through the limitation period.

And that raises a much bigger question for Victoria.

Is 10 years long enough for structural building defects?

We have seen enough building failures in Victoria to know that serious defects do not always announce themselves within ten years.

Foundation movement, structural deterioration, water ingress and other latent defects can take years to become obvious.

Yet once the statutory period expires, the owner can potentially be left with the bill even where the evidence ultimately demonstrates that the problem originated in the construction of the building.

That is a difficult policy outcome.

If Victoria wants people to have confidence in apartment buildings, perhaps the limitation regime should recognise the difference between:

a cosmetic defect

and

a structural defect capable of making a building unsafe or effectively worthless.

I think there is a strong case for a longer long-stop period for serious structural building defects.

Perhaps 15 years.

Perhaps 20…?

But whatever period is chosen, it should reflect the reality of structural construction not simply an arbitrary period after which responsibility disappears.

The Maidstone owners deserve compassion.

But they also deserve a legal system that gives them a genuine opportunity to find out what went wrong and who should pay for it.

Because if a building can start sinking after ten years and the law can leave the owners with a $20 million problem, perhaps it is time to ask whether the 10 year clock is long enough.

BU Lawyers acts in building defect, property damage and insurance disputes.

This article is a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Recent articles

Book an online appointment with our Principal Lawyer today

Book an appointment